linking back to brembs.net






My lab:
lab.png
Reading the article "Why do we believe in god?" in the British newspaper "Guardian" it occurred to me that religiosity may best be explained by operant behavior. Actually, as a by-product of selection for operant behavior. This may not be an entirely new idea, but I nevertheless decided to summarize my insight really quickly. Several bits of evidence brought me to this idea:
First, The article cites work that intrinsically religious people (i.e., those for whom religion is an end in itself, as opposed to those who are only religious to fit into society - extrinsically) show lower levels of anxiety and depression. I still need to dig out the sources of these claims...
Second, a good animal model for depression, learned helplessness (wikipedia), generates depression by removing operant control from the animals. Humans with depression often describe their feelings as "having no control over their lives". Even flies show a preference for situations in which they are in operant control, demonstrating that operant control is per se rewarding. One of the symptoms of depression is a reduced sex drive.
Third, animals which receive food on a random schedule often tend to repetitively perform behaviors they were accidentally performing before the food was delivered (superstition conditioning). Such effects have often been related to the development of religion in humans.
These pieces of evidence support the hypothesis that religious people are less depressive because they have the illusion they have control over their lives. Since less depressive people have a higher sex drive than more depressive people (on average), religion, on average, will tend to increase the birth rate - a great prerequisite for positive selection . In other words, people who are able to evade depression by finding control over their lives (or the illusion of control) will have more children than people who do not. Thus, religiosity may be a by-product of such selection.

Posted on Wednesday 23 November 2005 - 09:31:36 comment: 0
{TAGS}

Render time: 0.0573 sec, 0.0042 of that for queries.